High Court Declares Hospital Detention of Dead Bodies Over Bills Illegal
The High Court has ruled that hospitals in Kenya cannot hold onto bodies of deceased patients over unpaid medical bills.
In a landmark judgment delivered on September 23, Justice Nixo Sifuna said the practice, common in many hospitals, has no basis in law and infringes on the dignity of the dead and the rights of grieving families.
“There is no law in Kenya that provides for a hospital’s right of lien over patients or their remains if they die while in hospital or while undergoing treatment,” Justice Sifuna stated.
He noted that detaining bodies as collateral for unpaid debts has been used as a tool of coercion against families already in distress. “It is oppressive, unconscionable and repugnant to justice and morality,” he ruled.
The case was brought by brothers Moses Mutua and his sibling against Nairobi’s Mater Misericordiae Hospital after it withheld the body of their late mother, Caroline Nthangu Tito. She had been admitted on May 22, 2025 and died on August 2, leaving behind a bill of Sh3.34 million.
After her death, the hospital transferred her body to its mortuary and charged Sh2,000 daily, which added to the outstanding debt. The brothers, both college students, said they were unable to clear the growing bill and that continued detention of their mother’s body was making their suffering worse.
Justice Sifuna ruled in their favour, saying hospitals should recover unpaid medical bills through civil claims in court and not by detaining bodies. However, he clarified that mortuary fees incurred are still payable and must be cleared before a body is released.
“Socially, the detention of bodies by mortuaries and hospitals for debt claims traumatizes bereaved families and disrespects the dead. It has in many instances been used to blackmail, embarrass, traumatize and coerce bereaved families,” he added.
The court ordered Mater Hospital to release Caroline Tito’s body immediately upon payment of the applicable mortuary charges.
This ruling is expected to change hospital practices in Kenya and bring relief to families who have long suffered the burden of financial disputes being tied to their deceased loved ones.
Also Read: Senate Launches Probe into Sh14.5bn Currency Printing Deal with German Firm
High Court Declares Hospital Detention of Dead Bodies Over Bills Illegal